Christmas is the time of year when most of us allow ourselves to become nostalgic, yearning for happy moments from our childhoods--and even our collective pasts. We feel a sense of nostalgia for our own past, but also for the past that we didn't experience. The 19th century is long gone, but it is emotionally satisfying and comforting to see Victorian costumes and recreations of the stone-cobbled streets of London during the month of December each year. Christmas TV entertainment is one of the ways we indulge ourselves in cultural holiday memories.
One of the joys of watching the Christmas installment Happy Holidays from Bing and Frank, from the short-lived variety series The Frank Sinatra Show is that it's nostalgic. Frank welcomes crooner Bing Crosby as his musical guest in this special color episode. You didn't have to see this episode when it originally aired on television in 1957 to feel the nostalgia of it. There are layers and layers of cultural Christmas memories in this episode. Let's see how many you connect with.
|Sinatra actually shares a writing credit for the song "Mistletoe and Holly," a song introduced on his 1957 album A Jolly Christmas from Frank Sinatra.|
Frank opens the show singing the song "Mistletoe and Holly" while casually trimming a Christmas tree on a very hip, fashionable bachelor apartment stage set. His good friend Bing Crosby drops by the apartment, bearing an armful of gifts, and the men greet each other while singing a chorus of Irving Berlin's song "Happy Holiday."
|What gifts do Frank and Bing exchange? Copies of their latest Christmas LPs, of course.|
Frank and Bing exchange punchlines and then duet with a jazz arrangement of "Jingle Bells."
|Over a cup of red punch, the friends sing a swingin' arrangement of "Jingle Bells."|
Hearing a group of carolers singing "Deck the Halls" outside the front door, Bing and Frank step outside to join them in song. Next thing they know, Frank and Bing find themselves in period costume as they join the group strolling through Merrie Old England in a Victorian London setting.
|Bing and Frank's voices occupy the lead with the carolers' voices serving as background.|
|Crane shot of the Merrie Old England set.|
Frank and Bing join the carolers in singing the traditional carols "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen," "Hark, the Herald Angels Sing," and "O Come All Ye Faithful." As the carolers roam the streets, the residents and shop keepers hand out drinks, fruits, coins, and baked sweets to them.
|The Christmas party and singing continues for the two friends back at Frank's apartment. Here, Bing solos on "Away in a Manger" while seated on the couch in front of the elaborate Christmas tree.|
Frank and Bing return to the apartment (back in their modern clothing) where Frank seats himself at the piano and sings “It Came Upon a Midnight Clear." Next, Crosby solos on "Away in a Manger" and the two men duet on the reverent tune "O Little Town of Bethlehem."
|Frank enjoying the uptempo jazz arrangement of "Santa Claus is Coming to Town."|
This is followed by two more lively songs; Bing sings "Rudolph, the Red-Nosed Reindeer" and Frank counters with a swingin’ version of "Santa Claus is Coming to Town." Seated in front of the fireplace, Frank and Bing together sing "The Christmas Song."
|LOVE the floor lamp (left background) and open fireplace (foreground).|
The final performance is "White Christmas" sung by Bing Crosby as he looks out a window. Ol’ Blue Eyes even joins Crosby on his signature tune. When the song ends, the men sit down to eat Christmas dinner as the credits begin to roll.
|Near the end of the song, Frank joins Crosby in the final tune "White Christmas."|
Frank Sinatra himself directed this episode, and each of the song performances (except the ones during the Merrie England segment) are a long take. This means there's no edits or cuts during a song. They don't make TV like this anymore! In the opening number "Mistletoe and Holly," while decorating the Christmas tree, Frank drops one of the ornaments but he keeps whistling while he bends over to pick it up off the floor! The song and the decorating continues despite the gaff. The music conductor for the series and this episode was Nelson Riddle. Riddle and his orchestra (off screen) provide background instrumentation for all of Bing and Frank's performances, except during the caroling segment where there was no accompaniment.
|The song continues as Frank bends over to pick up what he's dropped. The performances in this TV episode are recorded in one take.|
It just doesn’t get any better than this. This magical TV moment is so swingin’ Old School cool, it keeps your eggnog chilled. It's impossible to imagine a modern day equivalent of this magical Christmas moment; these are two of the biggest musical celebrities of the 20th century. And here they come together for a half-hour to entertain with old and new Christmas tunes, a brief moment captured on film that we can watch over and over again, year after year.
|Frank and Bing duet on "O Little Town of Bethlehem" with Frank seated at the piano.|
Pay special attention to the story presented here. In the opening, Frank is singing to himself while he decorates a Christmas tree in his apartment. It is as if the television cameras are spying on a private moment when two old friends come together to celebrate Christmas together. This takes place, we are encouraged to believe, in Frank's own home--a place so quintessentially 1950s, it looks like a wonderful, vintage museum. Christmas TV variety shows quite often take place on a set made to look as if it is the star's own home. Think Judy Garland's 1963 Christmas show as well as many others. Hosting a Christmas show from a domestic setting is an interesting (and effective) way of creating a warm, inviting yet personal feeling. It's like we're seeing Frank at home with his best friend Bing--a warm and fuzzy fictional account of how Frank spends his holidays.
I also love all the drinking! Not only do the two men share a glass of punch during "Jingle Bells," but they also inbibe while caroling door-to-door on the streets of London.
Returning to the layers of nostalgia in this episode. How many references to Christmas culture can you identify? Frank and Bing exchange copies of their own real-life Christmas albums--do you own a copy of each? The old friends greet each other singing the song "Happy Holiday," a song first introduced in the 1942 movie Holiday Inn starring Bing Crosby. Frank and Bing step back in time to carol in Merrie Old England, a way of participating in Christmas as popularized by Charles Dickens. The two friends together sing "White Christmas," not only Crosby's best-selling signature tune but one he introduced in the 1942 movie Holiday Inn. The popularity of the song also inspired the creation of the movie 1954's White Christmas--which also starred Bing Crosby. Have you seen both movies Holiday Inn and White Christmas? TV viewers watching in 1957 would have picked up on all of these nostalgic references.
|Crosby and Sinatra step outside the apartment to greet the carolers as they sing "Deck the Halls."|
As viewers in the 21st century, this TV episode evokes further nostalgia for our more recent past. It's a look at the 1950s, not only seen in the decor of Frank's amazing apartment but also heard in the jazz arrangements of the Christmas songs performed. Let us not forget the presence of Frank Sinatra and Bing Crosby themselves--two of the biggest performers of the 20th century, in the middle of their long reign over popular culture. We continue to hear their Christmas songs played on the radio each December. And, how many other Christmas TV variety shows have you seen set in what looks like the home of the star? This 1957 Christmas TV episode is available for viewing on DVD under the title Happy Holidays with Bing and Frank. Let me know what you think of it.
This piece about the Christmas episode of The Frank Sinatra Show is a part of a series about TV variety shows organized by the Classic TV Blog Association. Please check out the other posts in the blogathon at the following link: http://classic-tv-blog-assoc.blogspot.com/
Joanna Wilson is a TV researcher and book author specializing in Christmas entertainment. More about the TV programs mentioned on this website can be found in her book "Tis the Season TV: the Encyclopedia of Christmas-themed Episodes, Specials, and Made-for-TV Movies." Her latest book "Triple Dog Dare: Watching--& Surviving--the 24-Hour Marathon of A Christmas Story" was released in 2016. She is currently updating and expanding the encyclopedia for a 2021 release. Her books can be found at the publisher's website: 1701 press.com
*Support this website and its research by purchasing the books at 1701 press.com
I have never seen the The Frank Sinatra Christmas Show, but.. after reading your wonderful review. I think it would be fun to watch. I will look it up on you-tube.ReplyDelete
Thank you for commenting. I think its fun to watch too!Delete
Joanna, I was unaware of this special Christmas episode--it sounds like a blast! I was intrigued to learn it was made in color (in 1957) and the sets, judging from your pic with the carolers, were pretty impressive for a TV show. In the 1950s and 1960s, seeing either Frank Sinatra or Bing Crosby on a TV special was surely considered a treat, so getting two for one had to be amazing. If they had overnight ratings (like we do now), I bet that episode would have had a huge viewing audience. Thanks for covering this unique Christmas special.ReplyDelete
It is a great treat, isn't it? You've touched on one of the special things about Christmas TV episodes of variety series--they are almost always the biggest budgeted, most extravagant episodes of each year. They typically pull out all the stops--including extra special guest stars.Delete
While many Christmas episodes of TV variety series have been released on DVD, they are usually given titles that don't reflect the original series from which they originate. Based on questions and comments I receive, I think most viewers have a hard time identifying what they are actually watching.
This is such a fun episode! We've owned the DVD for several years, and it's always the first Christmas program we watch (excluding "Miracle on 34th Street," which we watch on Thanksgiving Eve). Frank and Bing are beyond cool!ReplyDelete
You're so right about the cultural references throughout this. It's not only a snapshot of what Christmas was like, it gives us a great idea of what Christmas was EXPECTED to look like. And that tells us as much about the era as anything.
Fantastic! Read this at work so I'll have to re-visit to view the clip. May have to also look into getting the episode on DVD. I have the "A Bing Crosby Christmas" and watch it every year. (I think that's the correct name from his yearly Christmas specials.) The image of "Jingle Bells" you include is reminiscent of "High Society."ReplyDelete
Hahahaha. Yeah, Bing and Frank sharing drinks by the bar--it IS just like High Society!! Good on you!Delete
Target released it this year (2014) on a combo CD/DVD of Frank's classic Jolly Christmas albumReplyDelete
This recently aired on GET TV, and we recorded it. Everything you and the other commenters mentioned is on display. Bing's Christmas album was one my parents had, and was in constant use along with Mitch Miller and the Gang. Frank was too modern for them, but is one of my favorites. For we kids of a certain age, this takes me back to a time when my folks were still around, and things were simpler, at least from my perspective. Did anyone catch the gentle sparring in the beginning when they were exchanging their own holiday albums as gifts? In the recent retrospective on Bing, he was quoted as saying that Frank was the kind of voice that only comes along once in a generation...but why did he have to come along in mine?ReplyDelete
Just been aired again Christmas Eve 2015 on Channel 5 here in the UK.ReplyDelete
I love this special. I have been watching this for the past two Xmas', we had it on our DVR, then last night I saw that iTunes had it so I bought it, just now as I was checking it out on my iTunes account I suddenly wondered if this was shown on TV or in theaters as a short, because I wasn't sure if there were color TV's in 1957. So I did a quick Google search and here I am. I didn't know that it was part of Frank's show, thanks for clearing that up. You missed one gaff that always brings a smile to my face, when Frank and Bing are singing Jingle Bells over the punch, Bing sort of chokes on the refreshment, they both chuckle but keep on singing, I always find that hilarious. Two pros at their best.ReplyDelete
I watch this every year...for me, it's the perfect Christmas special.ReplyDelete
I've heard told that Bing pre-recorded his performances and lip synced to them, but that Frank preferred to sing live (which is evident when he goes a bit flat in the opening number, "Mistletoe and Holly", and in the duet on "White Christmas", when he misses a cue).
In addition to dropping the ornament during the first song, he also clearly got his fingers sticky from the candy canes, and it really seems to be bugging him; he gives his finger a quick lick, but then keeps rubbing them throughout the song, apparently trying to wipe the candy off.
And you tell me: when the carolers first appear outside the door, is that a young and relatively unknown Andy Willams standing in front on the left? I do believe I can hear Thurl ("You're a Mean One, Mr. Grinch") Ravenscroft lending his bass vocals to the choir.
I just noticed the Brady Horse statue in the background of your screensnap when they're singing "O Little Town of Bethlehem". That horse gets around.ReplyDelete