I've heard it said that a television series' best Christmas episode is the always the first one produced. That's not always true but it seems generally true. However, the eighth season episode of Little House on the Prairie
might be the exception to the rule. A few years ago, I wrote about the first season Christmas episode of LHOP
which is an adaptation of O.Henry's short story "The Gift of the Magi." Let me remind you of the outstanding eighth season episode entitled "A Christmas They Never Forgot" and then you tell me which of the two episodes is your favorite.
|The Ingalls host a full house this Christmas.|
1981's "A Christmas They Never Forgot" begins with Hester Sue arriving at the homestead to share Christmas Eve dinner with the Ingalls family. As a surprise, she has brought with her Mary and Adam who have just arrived by stage from New York. This Christmas is a special one with the expanded family and their friends gathered together around the dinner table--there's Ma and Pa Ingalls, Mary and Adam, Laura and Almanzo, Carrie and Grace, Albert, James and Cassandra, and Hester Sue. After the meal, they notice that a snow storm has made it impossible for the visitors to leave--and everyone begins preparations for spending the night at the Ingalls' home.
|Ma Ingalls reminisces about an especially meaningful Christmas from her childhood.|
As the children one by one drift off to bed, the adults continue the conversation around the dining table. Asked about her beautiful necklace, mother Caroline shares a story of a previous Christmas when she was given the piece of jewelry. We see Caroline's story as she tells it, as a reflection back to the time when she was young--just about Carrie's age, she explains. The first Christmas after her father died was also the first Christmas she was spending with her new stepfather. Caroline was still grieving the loss of her father and feeling a bit angry about having to spend this difficult time with her mother's new husband whom she considered a stranger. As a gesture of good will, her stepfather Fredrick gives the crying young girl a special gift for Christmas--a birthday gift he had received from his friend, Caroline's biological father. The gift was a men's watch fob with a chain. Caroline still wears it every Christmas to remind her of her father and the wonderful stepfather she's was lucky to have in her life.
|A very special gift helps young Caroline see how she is blessed. |
|Almanzo remembers when his big brother told him that Santa Claus didn't exist.|
As others in the party go to bed and Charles begins stuffing the children's stockings for the morning, Almanzo too begins reminiscing. The second story we see is Almanzo's memories about a Christmas he never wants to forget. He shares a story about the year his big brother Royal revealed a stack of hidden presents in the barn and told young Almanzo that Santa Claus didn't exist. Later, young Almanzo confesses to his father that Royal suggested that Santa wasn't coming because the gifts were already purchased. But his father very gently explains about the magic of Santa, inspiring renewed spirit in the little one. Sure enough, that Christmas Almanzo found that Santa did visit just as his father promised, however the naughty Royal didn't receive any gifts!
|Almanzo's thoughtful father explains that Santa's sleigh is only so large--it makes sense that Santa might stash toys all over the world ahead of time in order to ensure he meets his Christmas deadline. This was just the response young Almanzo was wanting to hear.|
As the night wears on, the severe snow storm begins to worry several of the adults still gathered, sharing conversation around the dining table. The barn door has blown off its hinges and a piece of wood crashes into the side of the Ingalls' home. After making temporary repairs, Almanzo and Charles come back through the front door covered in snow from the outside storm. This sight reminds Laura of a cherished Christmas memory from years before which she shares with the group.
|Mr. Edwards (Victor French) as he enters the Ingalls home, many years ago.|
Seeing Almanzo and Pa covered in snow reminds her of the family's first Christmas in Kansas--when Mr. Edwards came to visit. After a long journey through stormy weather, Mr. Edwards arrived at the cabin with gifts for both Mary and Laura. Edwards explained that as he was leaving Independence (Missouri), he met Santa Claus on the street. The elderly, fat Santa was worried about making the trip to the Ingalls' home so he asked Edwards if he'd bring the girls' gifts on his behalf! That Christmas, Mary and Laura each got their own tin drinking cup, a stick of peppermint candy, mittens, a cookie, and a penny.
|The girls are glued to Mr. Edwards' story about meeting Santa Claus in Independence.|
As the blizzard rages outside, most of the adults still can't sleep. Hester Sue offers to share her memories of a previous Christmas she'll never forget. Hester Sue explains that one Christmas during the Civil War when she was about ten years old, she went to the store with her friend to talk to Santa Claus--but she wasn't allowed in the store because she was black. Standing outside the store, Hester Sue spoke with two young, African-American boys who explain that Santa Claus was white and he didn't visit black children. Hester Sue could see through the window that the store's Santa Claus was white but she didn't know if she should trust the boys.
|Hester Sue shares a painful memory from her past, a time when she feared Santa didn't visit African-American children.|
That night, Hester Sue spoke to her parents about Santa Claus coming to visit and they reassured her about Santa. Later that night, Hester Sue woke up from her bed and saw Santa Claus leaving an angel doll within the branches of the family's Christmas tree. Not only did she see Santa leave her a gift--but she saw that Santa was a black man! Hester Sue explains to her friends listening around the dining table that that Christmas was an important one to her--and only years later did she learn that it was her own father who "borrowed" his boss' Santa suit in order to surprise his own daughter.
|Young Hester Sue is relieved to find that Santa Claus loves her too! |
|Charles opens the front door on Christmas morning to find a wall of snow! They're snowed in.|
The episode ends when everyone in the Ingall's house wakes up on Christmas morning to discover that the snow has accumulated over the top of the front door! Charles grabs his snow shoes and climbs out the second-story loft window to walk on top of the snow drifts to reach the barn. There he retrieves the family's hidden Christmas presents. This year, the family observed another meaningful Christmas--because they were together.
|This family listens to and shares its treasured memories with each other. I love that.|
I think this is an exceptional Christmas episode for several different reasons. One reason is because of the four stories shared by Caroline, Almanzo, Laura, and Hester Sue. Loyal readers of this blog know that I love it when Christmas programs are about sharing Christmas memories. As I've stated before, reminiscing is as much a Christmas tradition as decorating the tree and singing carols--so I love it when our favorite TV characters also engage in remembering. I've already written about a few of these, including Truman Capote's A Christmas Memory
and A Child's Christmas in Wales.
Even the movie A Christmas Story
features a voiced-over narrator reminiscing about his past.
|Don't you reminisce at Christmas too?|
Hester Sue expresses that THIS is another Christmas she'll never forget because she's with the people she loves. I love that doubling--that four members of the group tell stories about four holidays they'll never forget, in turn inspiring another memorable Christmas! That's good TV writing there.
|Laura's story segment actually comes from the original 1974 pilot movie for the series.|
|Hester Sue listening to Laura's story. Here, Laura's all grown up!|
A second reason I find this Christmas episode to be exceptional is that three of the four stories are original material--it's not a rehashing of clips from previous episodes. Extra effort was made by the people who made this episode to shoot original material. However, in the case of Laura's memory of Mr. Edwards--the story is derived from clips from Christmas scenes in the original 1974 pilot movie also titled Little House on the Prairie
. So when we see young Mary and young Laura--that's really Melissa Anderson and Melissa Gilbert in 1974--more than seven years earlier! If they chose to recycle clips from previously shot material, I love that they chose to pull from the pilot movie.
|I grew up in the 1970s so this is the book cover art I remember. Did you ever read the series of books written by Laura Ingalls Wilder?|
If that's not awesome enough, you should know that the Christmas scenes from the 1974 movie (and this 1981 episode) are actually adapted from the chapter "Mr. Edwards Meets Santa Claus" from the book Little House on the Prairie,
written by Laura Ingalls Wilder. Fans of the original books know that quite a bit was changed when the TV series was created. Yet--this Christmas story from the book was faithfully recreated in the pilot movie and then included in this Christmas memories episode. I love that!
|Hester Sue also sings a gospel-inspired carol "Sweet Little Jesus Boy" in this episode. I love that.|
A third reason this episode is outstanding to me is Hester Sue's story. Not only is the story emotional and full of the Christmas spirit but it touches on a crucial part of her character's identity. She doesn't have to explain how difficult it must have been to have grown up with a sense of self-pride after having been born into slavery. (Her story includes the detail that she lived on a plantation during the Civil War.) Even though she is told that Christmas is for white people, Hester Sue's parents try to convince her that Santa loves and cares for her and that Christmas is about inclusion. It's extraordinary TV that she's able to share her story about a painful Christmas in a new community that accepts her an an equal and values her contributions and friendship.
|Anyone else a Green Acres fan? Tom Lester also plays Eb Dawson.|
A fourth reason I think this Christmas episode is exceptional is because it includes a couple of notable guest stars. I'm a TV junkie so I immediately recognize actor Tom Lester playing Almanzo's father in his story. This same segment also features child actor Jerry Supiran playing the young Almanzo. His face may be recognizable to those that grew up watch Small Wonder
--a TV sitcom that has grown to cult status in recent years.
|Young Almanzo played by Jerry Supiran.|
While I love love love the first Christmas episode of Little House on the Prairie
("Christmas at Plum Creek"), I'm also willing to claim that this eighth season Christmas episode is at least its equal. Anyone agree with me? Do you have other examples of favorite Christmas episodes that were created late in a TV series' run?
tough answer. as to which was better.....loved the 1974 for the focus on their family, but also loved the 1981 vignettes of the past christmas' of different characters. i also thought that the christmas scene in the pilot episode was so touching. i wonder why they didnt do a christmas episode every year?ReplyDelete
Why didn't they make a new Christmas episode each year? That's a good question! Some series obviously did. I do remember that LHOP re-ran their 1st season Christmas episode each holiday season for years--that has been a common practice for many other series too. I do appreciate that when LHOP made a Christmas episode, they did it right!Delete
I loved both of them. 1. They showed the girls little and what LIW did to give her Mother a stove, that show a lot of respect and love.ReplyDelete
2. this one showed the girls grown and married and how families then spent Christmas. As for the blizzard, Micheal Landon took this out of the book Long Winter, and changed a few things as they have to in TV Series. In De Smet, S.D. and Walnut Grove, Mn in LIW time era there were many blizzards, this is same today. Ingalls family living in town ( De Smet) Laura was able to go up to her room and see the horse hoofs walking down the street from her window. Now in this time era, the house were not as tall as today. They were really snowed in 1880-81.
In anyone has been in these towns in the winter months you will understand it. Dean Butler was in De Smet a few years ago and a blizzard hit, he said he walked out side in the blizzard, as the wind blew and the snow hit him in the face, and the very cold temps., Dean could understand more what it was like to be in LIW time era, trying to traveling in a covered wagon, many could freeze to death trying to travel.
IN the LH in last Christmas episode, the average temp., in the house was 45 degrees with a fire burning in the fireplace, this was why it was important to keep the fire burning. It was a way to tell stories out of LIW books all in one episode. We have to remember the Ingalls family was on the poor side of living, where the Wilder family was on the rich side of living. Many episodes were taken from the books, but Michael would just change some things around to get a message across.
We today with a big family know how long it takes to prepare a Christmas dinner for a family with all our modern items but, can even think how much harder it would of been back then to prepare a family dinner, even though on #2 the food was not the
type of dinner a pioneer family would have had, but the message was spend memories and Christmas with your loved ones, even if you are shut in by a blizzard. As for Hester Sue her story was the most touching to even think of being a slave and not having a normal Christmas as the Master children did.
But as Hester Sue said she was with family, and the Ingalls family welcomed her with open arms and they did see a color they saw the person.
I still like the original the best. I love Hester Sue's story--it reminds me a little of the Langston Hughes story "One Christmas Eve" with a lot happier ending--but as a history addict I can't get by the historical inaccuracies, especially the wrapping paper on the gifts and the way Caroline smart-mouths her stepfather.ReplyDelete